J 2015

Czech economic historians and interdisciplinary approach

VOKOUN, Marek and František STELLNER

Basic information

Original name

Czech economic historians and interdisciplinary approach

Name in Czech

Čeští ekonomičtí historici a mezioborový přístup

Authors

VOKOUN, Marek and František STELLNER

Edition

Économies et Sociétés, Paříž, Cahiers de L´isméa, 2015, 0013-0567

Other information

Language

English

Type of outcome

Článek v odborném periodiku

Field of Study

60101 History

Country of publisher

France

Confidentiality degree

není předmětem státního či obchodního tajemství

Organization unit

Institute of Technology and Business in České Budějovice

Keywords (in Czech)

Čeští ekonomičtí historici; mezioborový přístup; historie; cliometrie; statistika

Keywords in English

Czech economic historians; interdisciplinary approach; history; cliometrics; statistics

Tags

International impact, Reviewed
Změněno: 29/9/2015 12:13, doc. PhDr. František Stellner, Ph.D.

Abstract

V originále

The paper analyses the current state of interdisciplinary approach in economic history in the Czech Republic. The results suggest that present historians do not have sufficient knowledge and experience when dealing with quantitative methods and other methods of social sciences as well. The state of research in the field of economic history is in fact not on the way towards more interdisciplinary approach. The analysis of selected publications revealed that the main method is historiography with general opposition to other social science methods and advanced statistics. The questionnaire survey results show that unexpectedly about 90 % of the respondents consider interdisciplinary approach helpful. About 60 % of respondents claimed that they used some statistical methods in their publications. However there is no evidence in the institutional analysis, examination of published or collective works, which would suggest any form of such interdisciplinary approach and use of advanced statistical methods. The results of the study also suggest that Czech economic historians, especially in the field of modern history, are willing to cooperate and use some of the advanced statistical methods but they tend to be very skeptical when it comes to economists dealing with historical matters.

In Czech

Studie analyzuje interdisciplinární přístup hospodářských historiků v České republice. Na základě analýzy produkce tří ústavů v České republice, kde je akreditována výuka hospodářských a sociálních dějin, bylo zjišťováno, jaké metody autoři použili, zda využili statistické metody a v jaké kvalitě. Následně byla provedena komparace a zjištění, že převažují jednoduché statistické metody a demografické metody. U části studií nebyla metodologie vůbec řešena.